INTRO
Welcome to Womble Perspectives, where we explore a wide range of topics from the latest legal updates to industry trends, to the business of law. Our team of lawyers, professionals, and occasional outside guests will take you through the most pressing issues facing businesses today and provide practical and actionable advice to help you navigate the ever-changing legal landscape. With a focus on innovation, collaboration, and client service, we are committed to delivering exceptional value to our clients and to the communities we serve. And now our latest episode.
Host 1:
One of the most significant fair lending developments this year involves the CFPB’s amendments to Regulation B. The Bureau removed Regulation B’s longstanding effects test language and took the position that the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, or ECOA, does not recognize disparate impact liability. That change has already been challenged in court, creating uncertainty for creditors across the market.
Host 2:
And while much of the public discussion has focused on whether the CFPB’s interpretation will survive judicial review, the article raises a different question. What if courts ultimately decide the CFPB got it wrong? Even if a court concludes that ECOA does allow disparate impact claims, there is another statutory provision that may significantly affect liability.
Host 1:
That provision is ECOA’s safe harbor. The statute protects creditors that act or refrain from acting in good faith conformity with official CFPB rules, regulations, or interpretations, even if those authorities are later amended, rescinded, or found invalid by a court. In other words, Congress created a mechanism intended to protect regulated parties that reasonably rely on agency guidance.
Host 2:
A key point is that the amended Regulation B rule actually became effective. The litigation challenging the rule did not stop the amendments from taking effect. As the article notes, a rule that is later vacated is not necessarily treated as though it never existed, which creates an important distinction when evaluating conduct that occurred during the period the amended rule was in force.
Host 1:
The practical implication is interesting. A future court could determine that ECOA authorizes disparate impact liability while still concluding that creditors are shielded from liability for conduct undertaken during the effective period of the amended regulation. That would separate the question of what the law means from the question of whether damages or remedies are available for past conduct.
Host 2:
The article suggests that if courts recognize the statutory safe harbor, any revival of disparate impact liability could largely operate prospectively. Combined with statutes of limitation and other procedural defenses, that could significantly narrow the pool of actionable claims tied to the period when the amended regulation was effective.
Host 1:
But that does not end the analysis. The real debate may shift to what it means to act in “good faith” and “in conformity” with the amended rule. Historically, safe harbor cases often involve specific agency instructions, model forms, required disclosures, or other concrete guidance. Courts can compare a creditor’s actions against those prescribed requirements.
Host 2:
Here, however, the situation is different. The amended Regulation B does not require a disclosure, establish a form, or prescribe a particular compliance procedure related to disparate impact. Instead, it reflects the CFPB’s legal position that disparate impact liability is not part of ECOA. That creates a more complicated question regarding what exactly creditors must have done to demonstrate conformity with the rule.
Host 1:
Creditors may argue that conformity simply means operating under a regulatory framework where disparate impact is not a governing legal standard. Plaintiffs, on the other hand, may contend that safe harbor protection should require something more specific than reliance on a generally favorable regulation. Because there is limited precedent addressing a scenario like this, courts may eventually be asked to draw those boundaries.
Host 2:
For compliance and risk management teams, the article’s final takeaway is particularly important. Even if the safe harbor provides meaningful protection against disparate impact claims, it does not eliminate other fair lending obligations. ECOA’s prohibitions against intentional discrimination, disparate treatment, and proxy discrimination remain in place, and institutions must still consider the Fair Housing Act and applicable state law requirements.
Host 1:
That means organizations should be cautious about treating the Regulation B amendments as a signal to scale back fair lending oversight. The article emphasizes that testing, monitoring, governance, and broader risk management practices remain essential. Regulatory interpretations may evolve, but core compliance fundamentals continue to matter.
Host 2:
Looking ahead, creditors should closely watch both the litigation challenging the amendments and any future regulatory action that could further revise Regulation B. The outcome may determine not only the future of disparate impact theory under ECOA, but also how courts interpret the scope of statutory safe harbor protections when regulated entities rely on agency rules that later come under scrutiny.
OUTRO
Thank you for listening to Womble Perspectives. If you want to learn more about the topics discussed in this episode, please visit the show notes where you can find links to related resources mentioned today. The show notes also have more information about our attorneys who provided today's insights, including ways to reach out to them. Don't forget to subscribe via your podcast player of choice so that you never miss an episode. Thank you again for listening.