Defending Data Breach Class Actions: Strategies for Businesses

Data breaches are a modern business nightmare. Not only do they compromise sensitive customer information, but they also open the floodgates for legal consequences, especially in the form of data breach class actions. Over the past year alone, data breach class action filings have tripled, with businesses across numerous industries, especially healthcare, finance, and credit rating agencies, finding themselves in the legal hot seat. 

Read the article
Defending Data Breach Class Actions

About the author
Mark P. Henriques

Transcript

Welcome to Womble Perspectives, where we explore a wide range of topics, from the latest legal updates to industry trends to the business of law. Our team of lawyers, professionals and occasional outside guests will take you through the most pressing issues facing businesses today and provide practical and actionable advice to help you navigate the ever changing legal landscape.

With a focus on innovation, collaboration and client service. We are committed to delivering exceptional value to our clients and to the communities we serve. And now our latest episode.

Data breaches are a modern business nightmare. Not only do they compromise sensitive customer information, but they also open the floodgates for legal consequences, especially in the form of data breach class actions. Over the past year alone, data breach class action filings have tripled, with businesses across numerous industries, especially healthcare, finance, and credit rating agencies, finding themselves in the legal hot seat.  

These lawsuits carry significant financial and reputational risks. Penalties can be astronomical, as evidenced by Marriott’s $52 million settlement in 2024. Worse still, the stock price for affected businesses often takes an immediate hit, with financial companies experiencing losses of up to 17% shortly after breaches are publicly disclosed.  

For businesses, preparedness should be a priority. Understanding the complexity of data breach lawsuits, developing strong defenses, and implementing preventative measures can make the difference between successfully navigating a breach and facing devastating consequences. This guide dives deep into the rising trend of data breach class actions, strategies for defense, and how your company can mitigate risks.  

Businesses often face allegations in lawsuits related to data breaches, with plaintiffs claiming failures in key areas. These include not implementing adequate cybersecurity measures to prevent breaches, failing to provide timely and transparent notifications about breaches, and misleading customers about the company’s cybersecurity capabilities.

The legal foundation for these claims typically revolves around allegations of negligence, breach of contract, invasion of privacy, and violations of state consumer protection laws. For plaintiffs to pursue a class action, they must show that the affected group, or "class," shares common interests, injuries, and legal claims. However, one of the biggest challenges for plaintiffs is proving injury, which often depends on whether the stolen data has been misused. This issue of standing remains a significant legal hurdle in these cases.

When facing data breach class actions, businesses have several legal strategies they can use to defend themselves effectively.

One key defense is challenging the plaintiff's standing. In these lawsuits, plaintiffs must demonstrate sufficient harm to proceed, but courts often differ in what they consider adequate harm. This creates an opportunity for defendants to contest cases on this basis. A pivotal example is the Supreme Court's decision in Transunion v. Ramirez (2021), which established that harm must closely relate to traditional legal injuries. This ruling has been instrumental in shaping data breach defenses. However, there is ongoing debate among courts about whether the mere risk of future harm, such as identity theft, is enough to meet standing requirements. This inconsistency makes standing a central point of contention in these cases.

Another effective strategy is enforcing arbitration agreements. Many companies include arbitration clauses in customer contracts to avoid class action lawsuits. For instance, in Patrick v. Running Warehouse, LLC (2024), the Ninth Circuit upheld an arbitration clause, preventing the lawsuit from moving forward as a class action. This approach can be a powerful tool for businesses to limit their legal exposure.

Finally, substantive defenses play a critical role in data breach litigation. Companies can argue that their cybersecurity measures were reasonable and met industry standards. The case of In re Blackbaud, Inc. highlights the importance of leveraging expert testimony and state laws to narrow the scope of claims or even achieve dismissal. By demonstrating that their actions were compliant with best practices, businesses can effectively counter allegations of negligence.

Together, these strategies provide a robust framework for businesses to navigate and defend against data breach class actions.

Fending off data breach class actions requires a proactive and well-thought-out strategy. For businesses, the process begins with an early case assessment. This step involves evaluating the potential exposure and legal risks tied to the case. By conducting this evaluation early, businesses can make informed decisions about whether to mount a defense, negotiate a settlement, or attempt to dismiss claims outright.

Next, businesses should consider motions to dismiss or pursue summary judgments. Retaining cybersecurity experts early is crucial to assess the validity of plaintiffs’ claims, especially those related to standing or damages. Additionally, asserting arbitration clauses and identifying inconsistencies in the claims can help challenge the class certification and potentially weaken the case.

Challenging class certification is another critical step in the defense strategy. This involves focusing on the differences among class members to undermine the commonality of their experiences. By highlighting substantial variations, businesses can argue against the validity of the class certification, creating potential hurdles for the plaintiffs.

In many instances, settling a data breach case proves to be the most cost-effective option. With fewer than 5% of these cases going to trial, businesses often consider individual settlements or class-wide agreements, depending on the situation. Average settlements in such cases tend to range between 50 cents and $12.65 per affected class member, offering a path to resolution without the extended costs and risks of a trial. 

By following these steps, businesses can effectively navigate the complexities of data breach class actions and minimize potential liabilities.

While legal defenses are important, the best way to handle data breaches is through prevention. Businesses can take proactive steps to minimize the chances and impact of such incidents. First, investing in robust cybersecurity measures is crucial. This includes adopting the latest technologies, conducting regular security audits, and training employees to detect and respond to threats effectively. Managing third-party vendors is another essential step—ensuring they follow industry security standards and including liability protections in contracts can help mitigate risks. 

Additionally, having a well-developed incident response plan is vital. Regularly rehearsing these plans enables businesses to act quickly and efficiently in the event of a breach. Finally, securing comprehensive cybersecurity insurance can provide financial protection against liabilities that may arise from breaches. Together, these strategies create a strong defense against cyber threats.

Data breaches remain one of the most significant threats to businesses today, and the resulting lawsuits can have devastating financial and reputational consequences. By understanding the legal landscape and adopting a proactive approach to both prevention and defense, businesses can mitigate these risks effectively.  

If your business is facing a data breach class action—or if you want to strengthen your defenses—consult experienced legal experts who can guide you through this complex process. Preparedness is your best asset in protecting your company.  

Thank you for listening to Womble Perspectives. If you want to learn more about the topics discussed in this episode, please visit The Show Notes, where you can find links to related resources mentioned today. The Show Notes also have more information about our attorneys who provided today's insights, including ways to reach out to them.

Don't forget to subscribe via your podcast player of choice so that you never miss an episode. Thank you again for listening.